Top Banana - Phil Silvers and Original Broadway Cast - 1952 Vinyl LP Record
  $   50

 


$ 50 Sold For
Apr 23, 2026 Sold Date
Apr 17, 2026 Start Date
1 Number Of Bids
  USA Country Of Seller
eBay Sold at
 
save auction  

Description

Rare 1952 Original Pressing – Phil Silvers in “Top Banana” Original Broadway Cast Recording on Capitol Records S-308!

Up for sale is a complete, playable set of the original 1952 Capitol Records LP Top Banana (catalog S-308), the legendary Broadway cast album starring Phil Silvers in his Tony Award-winning role. This is the true first pressing on the classic red-and-gold Capitol “Long Playing Microgroove” label – not the later 1977 reissue (T-11650).

History & Significance: Top Banana opened on Broadway at the Winter Garden Theatre on November 1, 1951. Written as a star vehicle for Phil Silvers (later famous as Sgt. Bilko), the show was a smash hit with music and lyrics by the great Johnny Mercer and book by Hy Kraft. It ran for 350 performances and satirized the early days of television variety shows – loosely inspired by Milton Berle’s “Texaco Star Theater.” Silvers won the 1952 Tony Award for Best Actor in a Musical. The supporting cast included Rose Marie, Joey Faye, Jack Albertson, and more. A film version followed in 1954, but this is the authentic original cast recording that captured the live Broadway magic.

Track Listing (Side 1 / Side 2): Side 1: The Man of the Year This Week • You’re So Beautiful That… • Top Banana • Elevator Song • Only If You’re In Love • My Home Is In My Shoes • I Fought Every Step of the Way Side 2: A Dog Is a Man’s Best Friend • A Word a Day • O.K. for TV • The Man of the Year This Week (Reprise) + additional ensemble numbers (full 15-track original cast album).

Condition Details (very conservatively graded):

  • Vinyl: VG+ – Beautiful glossy black vinyl with only very light, superficial surface marks from normal play/storage. No deep scratches, no warps. Plays cleanly and quietly on both sides with excellent sound. Labels are clean and bright with no writing or stickers.
  • Jacket: VG – Original full-color front cover art is vibrant. Light shelf wear and minor edge rubbing, but no splits, writing, or major damage. Back cover has complete liner notes, cast photos, and production credits.
  • Complete set – Record + original jacket (no inner sleeve, as originally issued).

This is a premium collector-grade copy of a hard-to-find 1950s Broadway original cast album. Perfect for fans of classic musical theater, Phil Silvers, Johnny Mercer, or vintage Capitol Records pressings.

Shipping:

  • USPS Media Mail 
  • Carefully packaged in a new LP mailer with cardboard stiffeners for protection.
  • Ships within 1 business day of cleared payment.
  • International buyers welcome – please message for exact shipping quote.
  • I combine shipping on multiple items.

Payment: PayPal, credit cards, or eBay Managed Payments. Returns: Accepted within 30 days if not as described (buyer pays return shipping).

Thanks for looking! Check my other vintage vinyl listings – I describe everything honestly and ship fast. Questions? Message me anytime.


price rating